Show All Photos
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  1 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  2 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  3 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  4 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  5 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  6 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  7 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  8 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  9 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  10 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  11 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  12 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  13 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  14 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  15 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  16 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  17 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  18 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  19 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  20 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  21 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  22 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  23 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  24 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  25 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  26 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  27 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  28 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  29 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  30 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  31 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  32 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  33 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  34 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  35 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  36 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  37 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  38 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  39 / 40
Middle Cay Private Island , Harbour Island  40 / 40
Add to Favourites
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private IslandMiddle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Middle Cay Private Island
Rate On Request

Middle Cay Private Island

Harbour Island  Bahamas
7
5.5
Rate On Request
Rate On Request
We love this villa because...
it offers the rare chance to own an entire private island experience in the Bahamas while still being just minutes from Harbour Island. We love its blend of barefoot luxury and full-service comfort, with two villas, direct ocean access, and endless opportunities for boating, swimming, and island hopping. It is perfect for families and groups who want complete privacy without sacrificing access to world-class dining, nightlife, and adventure nearby.

Middle Cay Private Island Estate – Ultra-Luxury Villa Rental in the Bahamas

Overview

Middle Cay is an exclusive private island retreat in the Bahamas, offering total seclusion just a short boat ride from Harbour Island, Eleuthera. This 2-acre private estate features two fully appointed villas, direct beach access, optional heated pool, and extensive water sports—delivering one of the most exceptional private island experiences in the Caribbean.

Easily accessed via North Eleuthera Airport (ELH), just a short flight from Florida, guests are met and transferred by boat directly to the island within minutes of arrival.


Key Property Details

  • Private island: 2 acres of exclusive use.
  • Location: 5 minutes by boat from Harbour Island, Bahamas.
  • Accommodation: 7 bedrooms total across 2 villas.
  • Bathrooms: 5 full bathrooms + 1 half bathroom.
  • Sleeps: Up to 17 guests.
  • Property layout: Main residence + separate cottage.
  • Views: Panoramic ocean views from all areas.
  • Access: Approx. 30-minute flight from Florida.

Ideal for those seeking Bahamas villa rentals, luxury group accommodation, and high-end vacation villas in the Caribbean.


Exclusive Private Island Living in the Bahamas

Middle Cay offers a rare opportunity to enjoy a fully private island lifestyle while remaining close to the vibrant Harbour Island community. Guests can enjoy complete privacy or take advantage of nearby restaurants, nightlife, and boutique shopping just minutes away by boat.

This makes it highly desirable for:

  • Luxury Bahamas vacation villas.
  • Private island rentals in the Caribbean.
  • Exclusive group getaways and celebrations.
  • High-end family villa holidays.

Accommodation – Two Luxury Villas

Main Villa

The primary residence features spacious ocean-facing bedrooms, elegant ensuite bathrooms, and open living areas designed for relaxed island living.

  • Master suite with king bed, ensuite bathroom, and oceanfront terrace.
  • Two additional guest bedrooms with ensuite facilities and flexible bedding.
  • Fourth bedroom with king bed and ensuite bathroom.
  • Open-plan living and dining areas with sea views.

Guest Cottage

A separate villa ideal for families or additional guests, offering privacy and comfort.

  • King bedroom with ensuite and private balcony.
  • Family room with double beds and ensuite bathroom.
  • Children’s room with bunk beds and trundle.

Perfect for Bahamas family villa rentals and multi-generational stays.


Island Features & Amenities

Middle Cay blends natural Caribbean beauty with refined luxury, positioning it among the most exclusive Bahamas luxury villas.

  • Private sandy beach.
  • Optional heated ocean-view swimming pool.
  • Two private docks for boat access.
  • Alfresco dining area for up to 16 guests.
  • Multiple indoor and outdoor lounge spaces.
  • BBQ grill and fire pit terrace.
  • Beachfront leisure and entertainment areas.
  • Crystal-clear waters ideal for swimming and snorkelling.

Water Sports & Island Activities

Guests enjoy full access to a range of included water sports equipment:

  • Kayaks.
  • Paddleboards.
  • Sea scooters.
  • Snorkelling gear.
  • Private 22ft powerboat with captain (fuel additional).

Harbour Island is only 5 minutes away by boat, offering dining, nightlife, and shopping. Private excursions can also be arranged to sandbars, Pig Beach, turtle coves, and fishing grounds.

A perfect choice for travellers seeking Bahamas villas to rent with private boat access and active Caribbean holidays.


Services & Hospitality

Included services:

  • Daily light-touch housekeeping (4 hours).
  • Dedicated boat captain.
  • Concierge assistance.

Optional upgrades:

  • Private chef.
  • Butler service.
  • Grocery provisioning.
  • Babysitting services.
  • Massage therapy.
  • Laundry service.
  • Additional housekeeping.
  • Heated pool activation.
  • Larger boat charters (34ft Intrepid available).

These services elevate Middle Cay into the premium tier of luxury villas to rent in Caribbean destinations.


Why Choose Middle Cay

Middle Cay stands out as one of the most exclusive private island rentals in the Bahamas, offering space, privacy, and flexibility in an unmatched setting.

Key advantages:

  • Entire private island experience.
  • Minutes from Harbour Island amenities.
  • Ideal for large groups and special occasions.
  • Flexible luxury service options.
  • Direct access to world-class Caribbean waters.

Perfect for discerning travellers searching for Bahamas luxury villas, private island estates, and exclusive Caribbean escapes.


Booking Information

  • Base rate includes up to 6 guests.
  • Additional guests: $150 per night per person.
  • Automated pricing adjusts based on group size and dates.
  • Designed for both intimate stays and large gatherings.

Middle Cay – Private Island Luxury in the Bahamas

For guests seeking Bahamas villas for rent, exclusive island retreats, and high-end Caribbean villa rentals, Middle Cay delivers a rare combination of privacy, accessibility, and luxury service.

A fully private island experience where barefoot luxury meets world-class comfort.


Enquire Now

Secure your stay at Middle Cay and experience one of the most exclusive private island villas in the Bahamas.

Availability is limited due to the property’s private nature, so early booking is strongly recommended.

Please contact Worldwide Dream Villas today:

Explore More Villa in the Bahamas

USA/ Canada:  +1 347 707 1195 

UK / International : +44 1978 368531 

Email: [email protected]  

For luxury villas to rent in other areas of the Caribbean  visit: www.worldwidedreamvillas.com 

See more details...

Rates

Plan Your Trip

Amenities

  • Air Conditioned bedrooms
  • Air Conditioning
  • BBQ
  • Beach Front
  • Boat with driver
  • Ceiling Fans
  • Children Welcome
  • Private Garden
  • Private Pool
  • Safe
  • Sea view
  • Staffed Villa
  • TV
  • Waterfront
  • WaterSports
  • Well Equipped Kitchen
  • Wireless Internet
Bedroom : 7


Main House
Bedroom 1 (Master): King bed, ensuite bath, dual vanity, walk-in shower, oceanfront terrace
Bedroom 2: Two full beds, ensuite bath with rain shower
Bedroom 3: Two twin beds (convertible to king), access to hallway bath with walk-in shower
Bedroom 4: King bed, ensuite bath with walk-in shower

Cottage
Bedroom 5: King bed, ensuite bath with rain shower, private balcony
Bedroom 6: Two double beds, ensuite bath with rain shower
Bedroom 7: Twin bunk + trundle, access to hallway half-bath, balcony, suitable for children only

Bathroom : 5.5

Staff

  • Boatman
  • Concierge
  • House keeper

Policy

Check In: 
04 PM
Check Out: 
10 AM

Location

5 minute boat ride from Harbour Island

Have a Question?

USA/CANADA: +1 347 707 1195
BARBADOS: +246-432-6307
UK / INTERNATIONAL: +44 1978 368531

Get In Touch

CONTACT US

USA/CANADA: +1 347 707 1195
UK /International : +44 1978 368531
Barbados: +1 246-432-6307

Email : [email protected]

 

UK: 40 Knutsford Road, Alderley Edge, Cheshire SK9 7SF

Barbados: Indigo Courtyard, Holetown, Barbados Bb24917

Live Chat


A great way to communicate as we can answer your questions in real time. We are usually available 6 days a week between 9am and 8pm.

FOLLOW US

Subscribe to our Newsletter